I have 2 of the black sugar perfect. I wasn't sure what the different is. Apparently there are different kinds, like the scrub mask or cleansing oil. The tub is essential scrub 2x . A facial scrub featuring black sugar, refined rice wine, and botanical oils that transforms rough, dry skin leaving a radiant smooth complexion. Dead skin cells are gently removed, while skin is nourished and moisturized. Double the volume of the original Black Sugar Mask Wash Off. It is a very gentle scrub. I feel like you should use this with dry hands and face to get the actual scrub. Cause when it is wet, it just turns soapy. Which is fine. But not exactly a scrub kind of scrub. With wet skin, I feel you can use this daily. Also, my skin feels sort of smooth after. Like it doesn't really dry it off. So it is actually nice. It is just not the kind of scrub I expected. The tube is scrub foam . A gentle and effective scrub foam featuring black sugar granules, refined rice wine, and botanical oils t...