I was given these and I have no idea what they were. The formula feels like serums. I am not sure if both are the same or different. I take it that they are different. And upon researching I think one of them is a lotion (right) and the one with the pump is a moisturiser. I may be wrong, but the moisturiser is slightly thicker. I don't really want to talk about these as I am not 100% certain what they are. But these doesn't really break me out. So it's not bad. Oh well, I just want to have this up on this blog cause I want a memory of this.